Well yes. Not exactly, but yes, in a way I was thrown out of a mosque today.
If you’re wondering why you don’t see any pictures on this post, that was in fact the reason why I found myself in a situation which turned unsavory enough.
For a really long time, I think it’s been like some 7 years since I first came across it, I found the mosque in Defence Colony a very enchanting place. For starters, it is HUGE. To find a structure so big, and belonging to a place of worship in one of the poshest localities of Delhi was something I always felt intrigued about. But then I only stopped by there for the occasional Juma (or Maghreb) prayers while passing the surrounding area, so couldn’t delve into the details either. The original structure of the mosque has a dome which gives out the fact that it has some bit of a medieval historical association, which always added to my curiosity.
Go to this mosque during any off peak hours (read as in between prayers) and you’d see rows of kids poring their heads over the Quran, humming and moving their torsos in harmonic motion as they memorize the book. Yes, the mosque also houses a Madarsa for kids, who are mostly from remote parts of Northern India, sent by their parents who may not exactly be in the best financial position to support their upbringing.
So I was going around with my camera taking pictures. Climbed up the stairs to take pictures of the dome against the sunset, chatted up with a kid who was from a village in Bihar, and who had memorized 18 chapters of the Quran, at the age of what, he looked like ten? Before then, I tried locating the Imam to speak to him and explain why I wanted to take pictures. He was reciting the Quran, so I spent some time waiting for him to get free, and though he did notice me, since he was busy I thought best to leave the talk for later.
Then the inevitable.
I had a feeling all along that there might be some places where cameras may not be as welcome. Which is why I try to be discreet when inside a mosque’s premises with the camera, and try to only take images of the external structure. It was much the same case here till now too, and I would have asked the Imam before taking pictures of the proceedings of the Iftar.
All of a sudden, I see this group of like 8-10 people running all around the mosque compound, while I was getting down the stairs. It didn’t take me much to realize who they were looking for. ‘Yeah, right, and so it begins’, was what immediately came to my mind. Though I still thought that I should be able to explain things and it should be sorted, after all there was nothing wrong in taking pictures of the external structure.
With like five people in my face asking my name, profession, reason for being there, and with me answering all of them, I reached the Imam and sat in front of him. I introduced myself, stated my purpose, why I was there. What followed was something that I would simply say was as good as putting my head inside a millstone.
The Imam simply refused to listen to me.
Hum kya jaanen aap kaun hain, yahaan kya karne aaye hain (how do we know who you are, and what your intentions are). I introduced myself again, someone asked for my ID, I passed on my business card. Now my business card is a plain white card with just my name and contact details, simply because after saying good bye to my ex-corporate avatar, I didn’t feel the need for any flashy logos or fonts on my card which spelt w-e-i-g-h-t. Unsurprisingly, the card just evoked smirks and guffaws from the crowd. Is par toh kuch bhi nahi likha hai!
I was beginning to lose it by then. Which is something that still makes me feel sick in hindsight. Not losing patience as a practice when you are fasting definitely doesn’t come easy in the real world.
I tried to be as polite as I could be, explained what a blog meant, told the Imam that I wanted to talk to him, had come to him earlier if he had noticed, that I wanted to know more about the history of the mosque.
Hum kya jaanen aap kaun hain, kahan se aaye hain. Agar masjid ke baare main aur jaanna hai toh Sir Syed jinhone Muslim University banai thi, unki likhi tareekh main sab hai. (How do we know who you are, etc. And if you want to learn about the mosque, read the history text which was written by Sir Syed who founded the Muslim University).
I told him that I had passed out from the same university he was talking about, and which history text by Sir Syed do I need to refer to? The Imam didn’t pay any attention.
Koi kisi ke ghar main aise ghus kar photo thodi leta hai. Aaj hamare ghar ki photo le rahe hain, kal hamari bahu betiyon ki photo lenge. (Nobody takes pictures like this inside anybody’s house. The next we know is that pictures of our daughters would be getting clicked.)
I just couldn’t make the bahu beti connection. And I felt like asking him whose house was it anyway. If anything, I was part of that house’s admin as much as anybody else.
I calmly told the Imam that I’ve taken pictures at Masjid al Haram, both of them. As usual, the Imam didn’t pay attention.
It just went a bit too far when voices started asking the Imam whether they should break my camera. I had half a mind of telling them, look, this cost me 90 grand, pay up, and you can do whatever you please with it. Didn’t do that, just asked in an assertive tone about the necessity of breaking the camera. Someone asked me to delete the pictures, to which everyone agreed. So yes, in full view, I pulled out each image on the preview screen and deleted every one of them.
Yes, some bit of me also got erased. But I think we are possessed with regenerative powers, so I shouldn’t think much about it.
With those glaring eyes around me, I just didn’t have any reason to have stayed back. Nobody asked me to stay back for Iftar, knowing that I had mentioned specifically that I was there to break my fast. Did it break my heart? To be honest, yes, it did. It became evident when I sat on the boundary wall of the park around Defence Colony market and broke my fast alone.
Now do I blame the Imam for the way he acted? No, and yes.
No, because I do understand that we live in trying times. He might have become scared, there might have been some background to his knee jerk reaction and I may have acted as a trigger. After all, there are numerous stories of clandestine ops being conducted in mosques. But then I didn’t need to carry a full blown DSLR to take pictures if I needed to do that? Wouldn’t I have been subtle if I had another objective?
Yes, because I still don’t understand the way he simply wasn’t looking me in the eyes while talking, and just raising his voice looking towards the mob of people for support in what he said. Because he was just not listening, not wanting to listen to what I was saying, let alone try to understand what I was saying. And as an Imam, I think he is supposed to be more open that that. An Imam, after all, literally means a leader of men. And most of all, even if I was up to something unacceptable, it still doesn’t take away the fact that nobody offered once to make sure I had Iftar when I walked away with like 2 minutes remaining for the due time. And for this, I would want to question the folks there, more than the Imam.
I feel bad, I really do at having had to bare this side of things too. Considering that the past few experiences have been very enjoyable. And I could have chosen not to talk about this. It’s just that this is purely a product of the times we live in, and the times we are building for ourselves by not trying to understand our environment, which is what compelled me.
I’m still going around with my camera to mosques. After all, each one of them is my house too.
And I’m not playing the victim here. The victims were the ones who confronted me at the mosque.
Sad,very sad
yes, that’s the only word which sums it up.
The reason i get peeved is that such display of idiocy has been and is very common in our region .. They have twisted the religion so much and there is no accountability to that.. but the things that do not affect (read as disrespect) the religion bring so much of the same to religious sentiments.. i mean… i am so sure that the Imam would have pictures of the two Holy Mosques printed on the calender by some local scrap dealer or someone hung in house and he goes on to object this..
Imams are leaders..leaders who should act the way they are SUPPOSED to be acting.. leaders who need to set an example by the way of deeds.. leaders who NEED to be friendly and WISE..
anyway.. i think i am ranting because of all the anger and frustration that i feel for the way we lag so much …and incidents like these are crude reminders …
Hope we see better days in the future ….
It is a sad incident that shows the shallowness of our religious leaders. The problem is that we can’t even make them realize of what they are doing. The religious sentiments take wrong twists and turns in these situation and being a humble person you can either leave the place or wait to see things going from bad to worst and stoop to a level not agreed by your conscience. But I should appreciate the way you handled the situation.
Shab-e-gham ae mere allah basar bhi hogi
raat hi raat rahegi ke saher bhi hogi
Peace!
Irfan
This is my least favorite post so far and it has got nothing to do with the way you write. Very disheartened by what happened here, but trust me I have heard worse stories about Imams, most of them true.
I had been to a Mosque cum Madarsa in Hua Hin (Thailand) with family. The Imam was very friendly and took us on a tour and put up no objections when we took pictures. He and the other people in the mosque invited us for tea and we had a good time with them though we spoke different languages. On that thought I wonder how would this Imam at the defence colony mosque reacted if you had been a journalist from some reputed news agency?
Thanks for posting this and hope to read more interesting tales from you!
This is quite sad. No other word sums it up. But you did right by not bringing in confrontation in the picture.
dunno if it helps but there are softwares that can actually even recover deleted pictures. I once accidently deleted pictures from my phone but was able to recover the images using a software and good part is its free
This is insane the way that man reacted and the rest of them who followed suit! Am angry and sad at the same time.. Next time Asif take me with you.. Will give them a piece of my mind!! ‘Bahu beti’ it seems.. And he calls himself a leader, some ‘leader’ he is!
Have you figured out the Bahu-Beti connection yet? My team of 10 has spent one work-day discussing this ;p . No result even at the end of a wasted day. Interestingly though, we realized having a note-worthy identity and a flashy business card.
Fear is provocative. Fear in the Imam caused him not to look you in the eye, caused him to raise his voice, wanted the mob to support him. Fear of a stranger in his familiar ground.
Do not take it to heart. We all have knee-jerk reactions when we are provoked.
Agree, summation of my post mortem of the experience too.
interesting experience Asif bhai. good to see you were able to get yourself and your camera out of it without harm. Nicely handled.
Spare some thought to those poors guys though..and I am not taking their side..but try making a list of all the types of people/agencies they can possibly mistrust and imagine you to be one of them and after their behaviour doesnt seem that unexpected.
I think the essential part of street photography is building the trust first( although from your blogs it seems you are already very good at it).
Anyway dont let this incident affect your blogs.
Awesome stuff..its making me nostalgic about Delhi
Saif, not at all letting this experience affect the blog. I’m still going around 🙂
Deelpy saddened Asif .. may Allah wipe out the slightest of ill bearing and grant the denizens of that mosque peace as well.
In my last visit to the Haga Sofia in Istanbul .. one can find a life size portrait of Christ done by the Christians and the the names of all Sahabas on the walls .. you ask any of the present day self appointed leaders of Islam and they will say it is haram to do so. Are they trying to tell me that those Turks in those days were lame or what :-).
South Asia and specially its Muslims suffer from this amazing austerity – do not know where we get it from …. been to the Mohammad Ali Mosque and the Blue Mosque … my fiancee prayed in one corner and I just a little ahead of her … tourists (I was also one of them) came and went .. with cameras in their hands … 🙂
Did that dilute Islam in any way … I guess … it strengthened mine … and healed the hearts that may have been goried by the hate-mongers. Allahumma Labbaik!
Chaccha, that’s an amazing experience you’ve shared. And I don’t need to say how much I agree with your POV. Thks 🙂
Ran into this Post as I was trying to gather some information about the past of Def Col Mosque.
Its a disheartening incident and the indifference of the caretakers even worse.
However, me being a resident of Defence Colony would like to share some stories I have heard about the mosque which might explain the Imams reaction to an extent but not justify it ofcourse.
The Imam has been fighting several cases in courts to retain the land on which the mosque is built and the land around it. Apparently the lands adjacent to the mosque property was a part of the mosque in the past which was usurped.
I dont know the details but I am sure that there must be many eyeing such a property predominantly and primarily because it is located in one of the most poche Colonies of South Delhi.
The Imams and the caretakers families live in the Mosques compound and that might explain the ‘Bahu Beti’ allegation.But the Imam shouldnt have dragged bahu Beti into it. Its just a polemic.
The Imam has also drawn criticism for making this mosque his ‘private property’ but I dont think there is a better alternative.We as Muslims (eps Delhi locals) have never really cared to look into the affairs of the mosque. The mosque is not well maintained inspite of decent collections they do on weekly basis and also in the form of donations. There has been some improvement, offlate, towards the same.
p.s- they should have invited you for Iftar. Insenstive!